A comparison of fatalism and determinism and their similarities

A great, bearlike monster, Grendel is the first of three monsters defeated by the Geatish hero Beowulf in the sixth-century poem Beowulf.

A comparison of fatalism and determinism and their similarities

A comparison of fatalism and determinism and their similarities

Some great philosophers have called philosophy the art of thinking; others have described it as the systematic study of human thought and feeling. Still others have said that whereas in real life people think about things, in philosophy they think about thinking.

So, here begins the initial journey of thinking about thinking. Because most philosophers also think about feelings--the meanings of artistic feelings, emotional feelings, and intuitions--feelings should be included, too.

In fact, there is one more step to take: Usually the word "perception" means what one sees, hears, smells, tastes, and feels by touch.

Some philosophy does examine external perceptions. However, there are inner perceptions, too: Therefore, it is possible to describe philosophy as the activity of thinking about knowing, or thinking about perception. Everyone is a practitioner of philosophy when he or she asks, "How do I know that what I think is right?

The Story of Early Philosophy Philosophy can be explained, as can most of the other humanities disciplines, by showing its history, its types, and its methods. Its history began long before written records were kept. It may have started when the first human not only perceived the sun, moon, and stars--and his or her own needs and desires--but also asked, "Why do these exist?

Perhaps philosophical thinking began even more simply in humans when they became aware that they could think--something like seventeen-century philosopher Rene Descartes' famous statement, "I think, therefore I am.

In 47 fact, written philosophy began at about the same time civilizations began to keep written records. The history of writing and the history of philosphy often, in fact, have gone hand in hand: Though the cultures that first developed philosophy were not in close contact with each other at the time, most of them developed philosophy at about the same time in history: In the West, the Greeks developed the first major philosophical systems starting about B.

Towering figures in philosophy--Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle ca.

Four contexts and contrasts

Socrates was put to death by his fellow Greeks for influencing the youth of his country with too much questioning and doubt, for he encouraged everyone to question all their beliefs, no matter how sacred or important.

Plato developed orderly systems of philosophy for moral, political, aesthetic the artsintellectual, and spiritual behavior. He especially developed a belief in Ideas: For example, a baseball is but an imperfect earthly version of the eternal Idea of Roundness or Spheroid Nature.

Aristotle, though Plato's pupil for twenty years, developed a different philosophy that emphasized human reasoning, de-emphasized belief in souls or eternal forms, and was more interested in analyzing and classifying what already exists in reality.

In the nearby Middle East, Jewish religious writers were creating the Hebrew Scriptures--what would become for Judaism its foundation and Bible, for Christianity the Old Testament, and for Islam important teachings and history. The first written Greek references to Jews refers to them as a race of thinkers.

As philosophy, the Hebrew Scriptures have in them a consistent belief in a single divine being, one who can be personally contacted and who helps humanity by ethical codes and divine intervention. In addition, later books such as Proverbs and Ecclesiastes contain philosophical reflections, and the book of Job is a profound meditation on the meaning of life and suffering.

The Song of Solomon also is sometimes given importance as a philosophical meditation on the meaning of beauty and love. In China and India, great philosophical systems also were developing at about this time in the history of the earth.

In China, a group of gentlemen scholars who also were government workers began to think and write about the meaning of government and society. The great philosopher Confucius, B.Thus, in Chapter 1 the conception of causal determinism is extracted, in Chapter 2 the relation between causal determinism and future contingencies, in Chapter 3 the relation between Chrysippus' determinism, freedom of action, and necessitarianism, in Chapter 4 the relation between universal regularity as used in empirical sciences, and causal.

In This Article

The comparison is both necessary and inconclusive, for some authorities maintain naturalism is an outgrowth of realism, and others, that naturalism repudiates the genteel premises of realism.

An additional complication is that some authors said to exemplify naturalism, such as Dreiser, are also hailed as landmark realists. While I would say their concerns are the same--namely finding a way of life--I don't think it would be right to lump Nietzsche in with stoicism though there is overlap enough I think to make an interesting comparison and I assume my professor thought so too, given the way she structured the course.

Background. Suboptimal treatment adherence remains a barrier to the control of many infectious diseases, including tuberculosis and HIV/AIDS, which contribute significantly to the . Determinism without such freedom reverts to fatalism.

A comparison of fatalism and determinism and their similarities

Another non-sequitur. Such freedom is not needed to avoid fatalism, as fatalism is not the same as causal determinism. These are two distinct concepts that share some similarities. One does not revert to the other. Matza and the Mood of Fatalism in the Desistance Process Mark Halsey.

Search for other works by this author on: Their mood of fatalism often resulted in ‘inward-facing’ infractions. (Matza’s soft determinism) that has implications for de-escalation strategies (see further below).

Fatalism vs. Free Will